As a general rule, the round, rubber soaker hoses are much more durable than the collapsible hoses made of plastic or canvas-like materials.
I'm curious, this is one of two identical posts. This actually happens quite frequently, so there must be some regular error or confusion. Perhaps there is a delay with posting a new thread, which makes it look like it has not been received. For now, I'll paste my post onto both threads, though I expect the content of each will diverge with time.