Maybe the Op should check out the impacts of those products
@cpp gardener recommends including how long they remain in the soil...I believe one should know that before using and that is NOT "self-righteous demagogues of Organic orthodoxy".
Just common sense. Something which is horribly lacking.
No concern about contamination?
A quick search yields this:
Dismiss facts:
Key points about the environmental effects of "Dismiss" herbicide:
Active ingredient:
The active ingredient in Dismiss is "sulfentrazone," which is considered relatively mobile in sandy soils, meaning it can potentially leach into groundwater under certain conditions.
Surface water contamination:
Dismiss particles can be carried by wind and contaminate nearby water bodies, potentially harming aquatic organisms.
Non-target plants:
Overspray or drift can harm non-target plants in the surrounding area.
Soil impact:
Repeated applications could potentially disrupt soil microbial communities
Sedgehammer facts:
Key environmental concerns with Sedgehammer:
Groundwater contamination:
The main environmental concern is the potential for Sedgehammer to leach through soil and contaminate groundwater, especially when applied in areas with permeable soils or a shallow water table.
Surface water runoff:
Rainfall after application can cause Sedgehammer to run off into nearby water bodies like ponds, streams, and ditches, harming aquatic life.
Aquatic toxicity:
Sedgehammer is highly toxic to aquatic organisms, even at low concentrations, and can disrupt aquatic ecosystems.
Non-target plant impact:
Sedgehammer can also harm desirable plants if not applied carefully.